Hi TT,
Don't rush off out to by a "digital" aerial as I believe you have a problem. According to wolfbane site your area is NOT yet covered by a digital transmitter. Neither the Matlock transmitter nor the one at Bolhill are due to go digital until 1st May 2011....
http://www.ukfree.tv/shutdowndetail.php?tx=SK297589http://www.ukfree.tv/shutdowndetail.php?tx=SK295552Are any neighbours able to pick up Freeview and if so which transmitter are they pointed at?
There are two wolfbane sites. One for Analogue and one for Digital. To work out what you need you normally have to look at the results from both and merge the data. By the way there is no such thing as a "Digital TV aerial" despite what some manufacturers put on the packaging! Aerials marketed as "Digital" are generally wideband aerials and these are to be avoided unless absolutely necessary because wideband aerials have lower gain than narrow band aerials!
First we head off to the the Digital site..
==========================
http://www.wolfbane.com/cgi-bin/tvd.exe?DX=M&OS=DE4%203PD&HT=10This says that there are currently no local digital transmitters and no distant ones either! This is probably because the wolfbane site takes into account the terrain (hills!) between you and the transmitters. For example if you tell it the aerial height is 75 rather than 10 meters it will tell you that you should be able to pick up the Waltham transmitter 37 miles away. For that you would need a really big wideband aerial mounted as high as you can get it. It would probably also need to be fitted with a mast head amplifier (not a back of set booster amp - they are the devils work). A local professional installer who knows the local terrain might suggest another transmitter and other aerial options but I do believe you would need a skilled professional to set this up at the moment - assuming it's possible at all. A tree in the wrong place may make all the difference.
Now to the Analogue site...
===================
http://www.wolfbane.com/cgi-bin/tva.exe?DX=M&HT=10&OS=DE4+3PDThis says your area is served by two transmitters. One at Bolehill 2 miles away and one at Matlock itself. These are very very low power transmitters - just enough to cover the immediate area. The table says you need:
For Matlock: a "Group A, vertically polarised, amplified extra high gain aerial.
For Bolhill: a "Group CD, vertically polarised, amplified extra high gain aerial.
Note: A "Group A" aerial is a narrow band aerial designed to cover the lower part of the TV band. It will have higher gain than a typical wideband aerial. A group A aerial pointed at Matlock will be also perfect for recieving digital from Matlock when it goes digital in 2011.
http://www.ukfree.tv/shutdowndetail.php?tx=SK297589Please don't let some cowboy put up a cheap wideband aerial pointed at Matlock because that's all he has in the van. A wideband is not really suitable for Matlock even if it appears to work.
Summary
======
You may have to wait until 2011 for digital but consult a professional to see if there is any chance of getting it from a distant transmitter before then.
See above if you want a new analog aerial. I'd be tempted to go for a large Group A pointed at Matlock, possibly with a mast head amp. This should work fine when Matlock goes digital.
Note your existing aerial might already be the correct type. It might just be old or need realigning or the down lead might be waterlogged.
Consider having that booster replacing with a low noise masthead amp. If you need to feed more than one TV use a low gain Distribution Amplifier rather than a booster.
Sorry for any typos. In a rush.